Arbitrator Scorecard

There are hundreds of no-fault arbitrators in New York. The list below shows arbitrators who have written awards in the last 30 days. More data on the individual arbitrators are available by clicking on the name. The percentage of awards decided for the applicant should be interpreted with caution. It does not distinguish between awards in full or in part, and does not factor in technical corrections or master appeals. The data below takes into account awards written in the last 30 days only.

Updated: 03/29/2025 12:47 AM

Arbitrator Last Award Date Number of Awards % Awards Decided In Favor of the Provider [AWARDED] % Awards Decided in Favor of Insurance Co. [DENIED] % Awards Dismissed (without prejudice) Arbitrator Award Search
Lisa Abrams 03/26/2025 62 46.8 50.00 3.23 Award text search
Michael Achtziger 03/20/2025 34 26.5 70.59 2.94 Award text search
Joshua Adler 03/28/2025 48 60.4 35.42 4.17 Award text search
Joanne Andreotta 03/24/2025 60 48.3 45.00 6.67 Award text search
Yael Aspir 03/25/2025 64 50.0 43.75 6.25 Award text search
Nancy Kramer Avalone 03/27/2025 56 39.3 57.14 3.57 Award text search
Thomas Awad 03/28/2025 63 52.4 42.86 4.76 Award text search
Elyse Balzer 03/26/2025 37 43.2 45.95 10.81 Award text search
Mona Bargnesi 03/27/2025 46 37.0 63.04 0.00 Award text search
Alana Barran 03/28/2025 58 58.6 34.48 6.90 Award text search
Rhonda Barry 03/28/2025 68 70.6 27.94 1.47 Award text search
Emily Bennett 03/28/2025 53 47.2 52.83 0.00 Award text search
Kent Benziger 03/28/2025 48 70.8 29.17 0.00 Award text search
Alison Berdnik 03/28/2025 68 54.4 41.18 4.41 Award text search
Inez Beyrer 03/26/2025 44 81.8 18.18 0.00 Award text search
Anthony Joseph Bianchino 03/28/2025 72 44.4 41.67 13.89 Award text search
Wendy Bishop 03/27/2025 98 68.4 31.63 0.00 Award text search
Charles Blattberg 03/25/2025 48 54.2 43.75 2.08 Award text search
Brian Bogner 03/28/2025 39 64.1 33.33 2.56 Award text search
Matthew Brew 03/27/2025 70 58.6 37.14 4.29 Award text search
Gillian Brown 03/28/2025 51 45.1 37.25 17.65 Award text search
Athena T. Buchanan 03/26/2025 55 36.4 52.73 10.91 Award text search
Glen Cacchioli 03/24/2025 47 36.2 59.57 4.26 Award text search
Maureen Callahan 03/26/2025 45 35.6 60.00 4.44 Award text search
Dinsmore Campbell 03/26/2025 76 48.7 46.05 5.26 Award text search
Lisa Capruso 03/27/2025 52 34.6 53.85 11.54 Award text search
Eileen Casey 03/25/2025 68 39.7 54.41 5.88 Award text search
Matthew J. Cavalier 03/27/2025 35 57.1 28.57 14.29 Award text search
Steven Celauro 03/28/2025 58 50.0 48.28 1.72 Award text search
Stacey Charkey 03/28/2025 71 36.6 56.34 7.04 Award text search
Jan Chow 03/26/2025 56 32.1 64.29 3.57 Award text search
Kate Cifarelli 03/24/2025 53 32.1 45.28 22.64 Award text search
Cathryn Ann Cohen 03/28/2025 48 72.9 25.00 2.08 Award text search
Bernadette Connor 03/28/2025 53 64.2 26.42 9.43 Award text search
Douglas Coppola 03/21/2025 34 70.6 29.41 0.00 Award text search
Perry Criscitelli 03/25/2025 55 45.5 49.09 5.45 Award text search
Ellen Cutler-Igoe 03/27/2025 38 63.2 23.68 13.16 Award text search
Stephen Czuchman 03/25/2025 74 63.5 33.78 2.70 Award text search
Tasha Dandridge-Richburg 03/24/2025 49 44.9 53.06 2.04 Award text search
Patricia Daugherty 03/28/2025 48 39.6 60.42 0.00 Award text search
Neal S Dobshinsky 03/27/2025 48 47.9 35.42 16.67 Award text search
Thomas Eck 03/28/2025 67 41.8 50.75 7.46 Award text search
Lori Ehrlich 03/26/2025 51 66.7 27.45 5.88 Award text search
Joseph Endzweig 03/26/2025 33 27.3 72.73 0.00 Award text search
Michelle Entin 03/27/2025 61 57.4 42.62 0.00 Award text search
Stacey Erdheim 03/28/2025 45 71.1 24.44 4.44 Award text search
Ben Feder 03/26/2025 47 70.2 25.53 4.26 Award text search
Rebecca Feder 03/28/2025 55 34.5 65.45 0.00 Award text search
Daniel Felber 03/22/2025 51 47.1 52.94 0.00 Award text search
Donna Ferrara 03/21/2025 40 30.0 65.00 5.00 Award text search
Linda Filosa 03/26/2025 70 42.9 55.71 1.43 Award text search
Karen Fisher-Isaacs 03/28/2025 51 43.1 54.90 1.96 Award text search
Jennifer Frankola 03/13/2025 38 36.8 63.16 0.00 Award text search
Claire Gallagher 03/26/2025 77 49.4 44.16 6.49 Award text search
Eva Gaspari 03/24/2025 78 59.0 37.18 3.85 Award text search
Vincent Gerardi 03/23/2025 52 51.9 46.15 1.92 Award text search
Drew M. Gewuerz, Esq., CPC 03/28/2025 46 47.8 47.83 4.35 Award text search
Teresa Girolamo, Esq. 03/28/2025 55 41.8 52.73 5.45 Award text search
Marcie Glasser 03/27/2025 62 29.0 61.29 9.68 Award text search
Ioannis Gloumis 03/28/2025 57 50.9 47.37 1.75 Award text search
Kevin R. Glynn 03/28/2025 46 54.3 41.30 4.35 Award text search
Valerie D. Greaves 03/28/2025 35 34.3 62.86 2.86 Award text search
Aladar Gyimesi 03/26/2025 46 58.7 36.96 4.35 Award text search
Susan Haskel 03/27/2025 51 31.4 60.78 7.84 Award text search
Brett Hausthor 03/25/2025 32 65.6 31.25 3.13 Award text search
Jeffrey Held 03/26/2025 33 24.2 75.76 0.00 Award text search
Eileen Hennessy 03/27/2025 66 10.6 74.24 7.58 Award text search
Lester Hill 03/28/2025 46 54.3 41.30 4.35 Award text search
Bryan Hiller 03/27/2025 49 51.0 30.61 18.37 Award text search
Pamela Hirschhorn 03/25/2025 42 57.1 38.10 4.76 Award text search
James Hogan 03/28/2025 29 34.5 62.07 3.45 Award text search
Andrew Horn 03/27/2025 33 48.5 48.48 3.03 Award text search
John Hyland 03/28/2025 49 36.7 61.22 2.04 Award text search
Debbie Kotin Insdorf 03/28/2025 22 45.5 54.55 0.00 Award text search
Howard Jacob 03/15/2025 18 66.7 33.33 0.00 Award text search
Hersh Jakubowitz 03/28/2025 47 40.4 46.81 12.77 Award text search
Paul Keenan 03/28/2025 39 69.2 28.21 2.56 Award text search
Shawn Kelleher 03/28/2025 82 48.8 42.68 8.54 Award text search
Theresa A. Kelly 03/27/2025 74 45.9 48.65 5.41 Award text search
Kihyun Kim 03/24/2025 55 50.9 41.82 7.27 Award text search
Mitchell Kleinman 03/27/2025 58 27.6 58.62 13.79 Award text search
Anthony Kobets 03/27/2025 52 46.2 53.85 0.00 Award text search
Richard Kokel 03/27/2025 53 30.2 67.92 1.89 Award text search
Michael Korshin 03/27/2025 59 45.8 50.85 3.39 Award text search
Amanda R. Kronin 03/28/2025 62 37.1 62.90 0.00 Award text search
Regina Anzalone Kurz 03/28/2025 69 47.8 46.38 5.80 Award text search
John Langell 03/28/2025 31 41.9 51.61 6.45 Award text search
Jacques M. Leandre 03/12/2025 25 44.0 44.00 12.00 Award text search
Nancy S. Linden 03/21/2025 45 64.4 31.11 4.44 Award text search
Bonnie Link 03/26/2025 49 53.1 40.82 6.12 Award text search
Melissa Regina LoFurno-Braxton 03/26/2025 53 37.7 58.49 3.77 Award text search
Mitchell Lustig 03/27/2025 56 53.6 42.86 3.57 Award text search
Fred Lutzen 03/27/2025 59 39.0 59.32 1.69 Award text search
Donald MacKenzie 03/13/2025 14 100.0 0.00 0.00 Award text search
Tara Maher 03/25/2025 41 56.1 36.59 7.32 Award text search
Ritesh Mallick 03/28/2025 52 51.9 48.08 0.00 Award text search
Anne Malone 03/21/2025 56 42.9 48.21 8.93 Award text search
Susan Mandiberg 03/28/2025 50 66.0 30.00 4.00 Award text search
Matthew Maroney 03/14/2025 22 18.2 59.09 22.73 Award text search
Frank Marotta 03/28/2025 48 56.3 37.50 6.25 Award text search
Richard Martino 03/27/2025 64 48.4 46.88 4.69 Award text search
Robyn McAllister 03/25/2025 58 43.1 53.45 3.45 Award text search
Melissa Melis 03/28/2025 48 52.1 39.58 8.33 Award text search
Evelina Miller 03/28/2025 65 40.0 52.31 7.69 Award text search
Samiya Mir 03/28/2025 25 28.0 60.00 12.00 Award text search
Maryann Mirabelli 03/28/2025 64 32.8 65.63 1.56 Award text search
Pauline Molesso 03/25/2025 51 62.7 27.45 9.80 Award text search
Tracy Morgan 03/25/2025 51 43.1 50.98 5.88 Award text search
Victor Moritz 03/28/2025 56 55.4 28.57 16.07 Award text search
Michelle Murphy-Louden 03/27/2025 51 58.8 37.25 3.92 Award text search
Camille Nieves 03/28/2025 56 41.1 55.36 3.57 Award text search
Rebecca Novak 03/27/2025 40 37.5 45.00 17.50 Award text search
Veronica K. O'Connor, Esq. 03/24/2025 60 35.0 58.33 6.67 Award text search
John O'Grady 03/27/2025 73 37.0 41.10 21.92 Award text search
Heidi Obiajulu 03/28/2025 59 66.1 25.42 8.47 Award text search
Felix Papadakis 03/27/2025 57 45.6 43.86 10.53 Award text search
Corinne Pascariu 03/27/2025 43 51.2 46.51 2.33 Award text search
Natia Pavel 03/28/2025 51 45.1 50.98 3.92 Award text search
Christopher Persad 03/24/2025 44 54.5 31.82 13.64 Award text search
Gary Peters 03/25/2025 67 41.8 50.75 7.46 Award text search
Tali Philipson 03/28/2025 76 56.6 36.84 6.58 Award text search
Stacy Presser 03/28/2025 42 50.0 50.00 0.00 Award text search
Preeti Priya 03/28/2025 78 50.0 41.03 8.97 Award text search
Michael Resko 03/27/2025 59 54.2 44.07 1.69 Award text search
Cathryn Roberts 03/27/2025 78 46.2 50.00 3.85 Award text search
Michael Rosenberger 03/14/2025 40 57.5 42.50 0.00 Award text search
Brian Rudolph 03/27/2025 53 32.1 62.26 5.66 Award text search
Ann Lorraine Russo 03/24/2025 47 46.8 42.55 10.64 Award text search
Antonietta Russo 03/28/2025 72 43.1 47.22 9.72 Award text search
Kenneth Rybacki 03/27/2025 73 69.9 28.77 1.37 Award text search
Phyllis Saxe 03/24/2025 26 57.7 38.46 3.85 Award text search
Nada Saxon 03/28/2025 78 35.9 47.44 16.67 Award text search
Allison Schimel 03/27/2025 82 50.0 42.68 7.32 Award text search
Alise Schor 03/28/2025 42 54.8 33.33 11.90 Award text search
Maria Schuchmann 03/24/2025 57 54.4 36.84 8.77 Award text search
Eylan Schulman 03/25/2025 56 48.2 48.21 3.57 Award text search
Alina Shafranov 03/28/2025 46 58.7 39.13 2.17 Award text search
Darren Sheehan 03/28/2025 69 47.8 37.68 14.49 Award text search
Jeffrey Silber 03/28/2025 69 42.0 50.72 7.25 Award text search
Nicole J. Simmons 03/28/2025 57 36.8 54.39 8.77 Award text search
James Skelton 03/28/2025 46 54.3 36.96 8.70 Award text search
Charles Sloane 03/28/2025 48 72.9 27.08 0.00 Award text search
Deepak Sohi 03/28/2025 80 43.8 36.25 20.00 Award text search
Dimitrios Stathopoulos 03/25/2025 45 51.1 44.44 4.44 Award text search
Farheen Sultan 03/28/2025 72 31.9 65.28 2.78 Award text search
Matthew Summa 03/26/2025 56 50.0 39.29 10.71 Award text search
Kathleen Sweeney 03/28/2025 55 34.5 60.00 5.45 Award text search
Nicholas Tafuri 03/25/2025 46 69.6 26.09 4.35 Award text search
John Talay 03/27/2025 66 43.9 50.00 6.06 Award text search
Diane Flood Taylor 03/28/2025 45 37.8 62.22 0.00 Award text search
Carolynn Terrell-Nieves 03/28/2025 56 44.6 51.79 3.57 Award text search
Mary Anne Theiss 03/26/2025 42 45.2 38.10 16.67 Award text search
Debbie Thomas 03/21/2025 55 45.5 43.64 10.91 Award text search
Victoria Thomas 03/28/2025 71 29.6 66.20 4.23 Award text search
Meryem Toksoy 03/27/2025 35 51.4 48.57 0.00 Award text search
Keith Tola 03/28/2025 57 70.2 26.32 3.51 Award text search
Giovanna Tuttolomondo 03/28/2025 57 42.1 52.63 5.26 Award text search
Marcelo Vera 03/27/2025 56 62.5 37.50 0.00 Award text search
Greta Vilar 03/27/2025 49 44.9 55.10 0.00 Award text search
Laura E. Villeck 03/24/2025 45 64.4 35.56 0.00 Award text search
Matthew K. Viverito 03/28/2025 61 70.5 29.51 0.00 Award text search
Gregory Watford 03/27/2025 74 52.7 36.49 10.81 Award text search
Paul Weidenbaum 03/27/2025 66 47.0 53.03 0.00 Award text search
Ellen Weisman 03/28/2025 51 52.9 33.33 13.73 Award text search
Gerry Wendrovsky 03/26/2025 30 36.7 60.00 3.33 Award text search
Glen Wiener 03/27/2025 55 56.4 41.82 1.82 Award text search
Philip Wolf 03/26/2025 71 29.6 60.56 9.86 Award text search
Laura Yantsos 03/28/2025 42 45.2 42.86 11.90 Award text search
Josh Youngman 03/26/2025 104 57.7 33.65 8.65 Award text search
Marianne C. Zack 03/28/2025 55 63.6 32.73 3.64 Award text search